Book Review: ‘Catch Her If You Can’ by Tessa Bailey

Book Title: Catch Her If You Can
Author: Tessa Bailey
Publisher: Avon Books
Number of Pages: 384
ISBN: 0063380870
Date Published: Jan. 20, 2026

Book Review

“Catch Her If You Can” by Tessa Bailey is a fun, light hearted marriage-of-convenience romance with plenty of spice. The story moves between the past and present, which can feel a bit confusing at times, but overall, it still keeps things engaging. Even though it is part of the Big Shots series, it works well as a standalone and delivers a sweet mix of longing, romance, and friendship.

Eve and Madden first met in high school. He is drawn to her but waits because she is younger, while Eve tries not to fall for him since her best friend likes him. Still, Madden only ever notices Eve. When she is bullied because of her father’s strip club, he steps in and protects her. They grow close but stay just friends, even when Eve supports him through his kidney illness and transplant. Years later, Madden becomes a professional baseball catcher, and Eve runs a struggling burlesque club.

They meet again when Eve is under financial pressure while taking care of her niece and nephews. Madden offers a marriage of convenience so he can help her with health insurance, and this finally gives them a chance to be together. Madden really stands out—he is caring, confident, and fully devoted to Eve. Their chemistry is strong, and the romantic scenes are exactly what fans of the author would expect. The “he falls first” trope adds to the charm.

Also Read: ’30-Something Millionaire’ Review: Achieve Financial Freedom in Your 30s

At the same time, the story feels a bit surface-level in places. Their emotional connection does not always feel as deep as it could, especially considering their long history. The timeline shifts also affect the flow, and the present-day parts feel stronger. Still, the writing is smooth and easy to read, making it a quick and enjoyable book. The friend group adds fun and warmth, and side characters like Elton and Veda make readers curious.

Books are love!

Get a copy now!